Tracie and I were introduced a couple years back to Settlers of Catan by another couple. We’ve met dozens of times since then to play the resource gathering and building board game. It’s a game that typically frightens new players, who find by the end of their first game that the movements are very simple, though the strategy can get fairly deep. Certainly not Risk deep, but as deep as a game can be and still be playable in an hour or so.
The board game costs under $30, but the difficulty is often in finding people to play. It can be played with three players, but isn’t really enjoyable unless four are participating. MSN games carries a version of the game online, but it requires a monthly fee to play.
A slightly more simplistic, and free, java implementation of the game can be found at JSettlers. I’m not sure how the original creators feel about this derived work, but it’s remained online and popular for some time now. Note that if you go type jsettlers.com into your web browser, by default you are taken to the Ladder Game area, where login is required and you are forced to play against human beings for rank. Click Host 1 or Host 2 at the top if you want to play casually or by yourself.
There are limitations to the online version. Though the bots excersize mostly sound strategy, they don’t tend to be amicable to trades. After my first rejected trade offer, I can’t convince them to make a trade with me, no matter how sweet I make the deal. “How about I give you three wood and two clay, for your one sheep. No?” I imagine that this is put in place to prevent players from taking advantage of a lack of bot intelligence, slowly ramping up the trade so that they can find the exact point at which a bot will make a trade.
Another limitation of JSettlers is being locked into the traditional rule set. It’s a good set of rules, but I had gotten used to some house rules when playing with Robert and Mel, so I had to adjust to playing the game the way it was intended to be played. Those whose companions usually play by insane house rules (I’m looking at you, Cal) may enjoy a break from the absurd.
I haven’t played any face-to-face settlers games since I started playing JSettlers, but I’m hoping that it’s doing a little to sharpen me for actual play. Regardless, it’s an enjoyable diversion that can be completed in about 20 minutes when challenging the fast-playing computer opponents.
